Best Pizza in Titusville

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in Titusville, FL at 2845 Garden St

Your neighborhood pizzeria since 1983

Featured

42 years at the same table

Nick opened Kelsey's in Titusville on November 26, 1983, at age 22. He grew up in the restaurant world and built this place on generous portions, quality ingredients, and treating every customer like a neighbor.

Garlic knots, pizza, pasta, and more

The menu runs from New England-style pan pizza to Greek salads, grinders, calzones, and rotating daily specials — something for everyone, every day of the week.

View the menu

Conquer Kelsey’s legendary Belly Buster

Meet Kelsey’s legendary Belly Buster—our most fully loaded pizza! Stacked high with savory meats, fresh veggies, sliced jalapeños, black olives, zucchini, and melted cheese on hot, fresh dough. It's the ultimate pie built to feed a real appetite.

View the menu

Made fresh, every day

Handcrafted daily using traditional family recipes, fresh dough, and premium ingredients to bring authentic Italian flavor to your table.

Welcome to our cozy dining room

Step into our cozy, rustic dining room! With warm wooden booths, charming decor, and plenty of space for families and groups, Kelsey’s offers a relaxed setting to enjoy authentic Italian favorites. Pull up a chair and feel right at home.

Italian catering for any event

Bring the flavors of Kelsey’s to your next event! From savory pasta platters to fresh salads and specialty pizzas, we make feeding any crowd easy and delicious. Celebrate with authentic Italian catering made fresh daily.

Request catering

Come find us in Titusville

📍 2845 Garden St, Titusville, FL 32796 📞 (321) 268-5555 🕒 Mon–Sun: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM (Open Daily)

Get directions

Excellent pizzeria and Italian food located in the heart of Titusville. Enjoy dining here each time in town. Service is excellent, and value is very good.

Ron M.

Tasty pizza, I have always gotten great service every visit. I recommend Kelsey's if you want to get away from the big chain pizza spots and try something really local.

Stu R.

The ordering process was quick and easy. Extremely fresh and delicious chicken ceaser salad (the ceaser dressing is to die for.) The cheese pizza was also super good!

C C.

Kelsey’s Pizza has been our entire family’s unequalled favorite for 20 years. In two decades Kelsey’s has never wavered. If possible, they’ve only gotten better. Our two favorites are the sausage and onion and vegetarian. This is definitely not “your same old pizza!” My taste buds shout ‘Thank you’, every time we go!

Tony T.